Official Rate the signature above you Thread

[Cloud]

Okay brawlers community, lets rate the signature above us, and give it a score out of 10. Okay lets start.

[Radian]

8.5 outta 10. the text could use a little work, the border seems weird to me and id be interested to see some colour effects on the render.[/criticisism]

on the plus side, i love the background and the image placement.

[Zantetsuken]

Do I even need to say it? It's ACE, he wins!

9.9 out of 10, cuz nothing's ever perfect XD

[Radian]

:oops: heh, thanks Zant.

hmm, i give yours something around 8.5-9 maybe 8.7

i really like the border, nice and simple, but it keeps the flow. i like the bluring, especially on the right handed Pit, makes him look more holy.

and now for the critic to come back. The Pit on the left, i dont like it(personally) The reddish in his wings and face go against the serenity and calmness of the rest of the sig. Maybe use a cleaner image or something. also im thinking a very simple light blueish background could give this sig a little more. not too noticeable, but enough to be there. the text could be different too. it looks nice, but maybe try Forte's technique next time. Final thing, the cut on the left Pit is a little weak in places, mainly the wing closest to the middle and the top of his head.

thats meant to help you ya know, so you better not take it negatively XD

[Ultie]

i will rate your stealth sig >=o

it has a ninja so thats instant +8 points. the background i like so thats +1 but the stealth animating text puts me off a bit. so 9/10

and for ur main sig its good and well made. but the flashing iritates my eyes :( so i give it 8.1232/10

[Jonus63]

k radiant ace rate mine but its ulties so yea :)

[Radian]

hmm, 9/10 maybe 9.5. i like it. alot. the border is something new, and unexpected, but it works really well with the whole sig. the text flows nicely and the image placement is great. i love the colour scheme as well. my one and only issue with this is that the render seems to have been put in as is. i would have liked to see its darkness or contrast edited, but it is a great sig.

[Romeo]

Well here's mine, my sig and clan banner were both created by me so lets hear what yall think of it.

[Radian]

jeepers creepers, am i the only critic here?!?

anyways, you sig is cool, but i absolutley love your banner. 9.7/10 the faces in the angle boxes are awesome (i tried to do something similar awhile ago, did not work at all XD) the stars are great colours for contrasting the background and the text adds gutso, but takes nothing away, its simple but efficient. i think it would look better if/when you fill it with more faces. my only other issue is the border, but i cant really put my finger on it as to why.

[Jonus63]

Oh got a new one i can rate that i give it 8/10

-it is animated :( (lol)
+i like the fire it looks like a real fire it would be cool if u could animate the fire

[Radian]

heh thanks jonus, but i like this one more (just switched again)

[Romeo]

much better, can't really decide on a rating but definitely an improvement from the constant flashing animation you had before.

[80P]

yeah i like that new one, i liked the old one too but i like this one as well ;)

[Radian]

heh, thanks. i like this one too, my favourite series with my favourite element.

[Jonus63]

oh and u got an animation under your sig lol where does it end? at the ... or the WAIT!

+its funny lol
-i dont know where it ends

9/10

[Radian]

"i can chill drinks too"

is the end

[Jonus63]

aha i thoguht it ended in ...

[Rockman92]

well mine is a RadiantAce production so u can rate it for him (yes it is megaman/rockman)

[baxterlehman]

not a big fan of the fatal brawlers but hte rockman sig is awesome 9/10

[Kurohyou]

Like your sig a lot there baxterlehman 9/10....

[kirby216]

here's mine it kinda sucks, but I really don't know much about that kind of stuff. Tiger's sig gets a 7/10 :>)

[[NeW]TearZ]

8 out of ten.

Ups: Creative. Colors aren't boring.
Downs: Pixelated. Cut out is poor.

Other than that, good job making it. I can tell its your own work and not copyrighted.

[SSJ4HP]

I give it a 9.5/10. I really like the blur technique and the opacity works, but even though I couldn't do better, it doesn't make me fall over in shock of awesome. Really good job.

[Aero-Star]

7/10 i don't like the text and i don't know it's not my taste in sig. lol

[[NeW]TearZ]

i like olimar's because im the one that made it for him. lol

[SSJ4HP]

Well, then. How about this new one? *Made it a few minutes ago. XD*

[DrkKnight]

9.5-10 very good try both of mine.

[Jonus63]

i like your sig under the first sig, especially the link and darklink transform 8/10 for the under and 5/10 for the one over the 2 charachters looks dark and blurry but i like the text.

[DrkKnight]

thanks jonus.

[SSJ4HP]

I already talked aboot yours, I was just going to say, the reason I picked that Toon Link is it is one of the only two pics I have ever seen TL angry.

[DrkKnight]

ive found tons of tl pick while searching for link good job with the sword slash

[SSJ4HP]

Yeah, he's not hard to find, but he's always smiling like "I's be a Swordsman!! Ayy!!!!!!!" *Big smiling face and Wind Waker.*

[DrkKnight]

not on photobucket and flickr

[DrkKnight]

i got a new one XD.

[SSJ4HP]

Very cool. I like Lucario. I give it a 9.7 out of 10. It is really close to perfect. I think I'm biased so that's why this doesn't get a 10 out of 10.

[DrkKnight]

i worked hard on the special effects and aura storm around him.

[SSJ4HP]

I think it deserves a 15 out of 10, but I don't think I'm allowed to do that.

[DrkKnight]

who cares just go with what ya feel lol.

[SSJ4HP]

If you have extra time, would you mind making me one similar to that with a Pikachu? If you can't or don't want to, that's fine.

[DrkKnight]

sure ill do it for ya.

[Radian]

I'm looking forward to seeing that, should be nice.

[DrkKnight]

thanks ace ill uses your border trick.

[Zantetsuken]

Dark, I see you're blurring more, getting better ^^ But Mario's arm could use some more.

The background is good. Simple, effective, it looks cool, but it's out of the characters' color schemes.

Everything else looks fine except the text, I still gotta teach you that bevel trick....

[DrkKnight]

yea you do and since this is the rate the sig above you thread ill give u a 9.5/10 i like the text effect and the pictures you found however i dont really like the middle lucario withut any effects.

[Radian]

i'll critique your sig too DL, i think i am one of the most veteran sig makers here, so hopefully i can give some good advice.

ok, i won't bother mentioning the stuff Zan said, but i'll give you some other things to watch for.

Your border is a little bit off. the inner light blue one is broken at the top and the sig extends out of the border on the right side. both are incredibly easy to fix, let me know if you need help with borders.

Your character choices. they are pretty varied, light green, dark green and pink, not to mention quite varied art styles. That makes it hard to make a proper background. its easier if you use one character, or all the characters from the same series.

And yeah, text needs work. But you are definitely improving, keep it up! ^.^

instead of rating the sig i have on now, rate the very first signature i EVER made.

http://i115.photobucket.com/albums/n286/laksom/starwolfsig.jpg

go ahead, rip it to pieces, it was my first ever XD

[Jonus63]

woo very........nes style and the gun looks wierd does it say noriorius? or is it just me XD wolf looks funny, like he was made of paper XD 4/10 the only good part is the laser. gg very huge ^^ wish it was that huge in brawl lol

[ellzyboy]

wavve sigs are simple, great and just damnright awesome :)

[Radian]

i agree with ellzyboy.

i need a rating on my new black knight signature, if its not too much trouble for anyone.

[ellzyboy]

black knight sig wons, like the grey with colour!
its cool (Y)
reminds me of sin city!

[DrkKnight]

well Radian i like how you make the backround effect filter over the black knight on the left, the Red line could use some effect to it like curviture other that that i ike it, very nice as usual.

[Radian]

curving the red line would interrupt the flow of the sig. when i first started, i'm sure i would've thought the same, but once you make 100+ signatures you start to know the little tiny nuances like flow and colour coupling and image placement and all the other things you might not think important really hit you.

[SSJ4HP]

Oy, I need a link to a Gimp program, does anyone want to hook me up, here? (Go ahead and rate the sig if you want, not my proudest work)

[Radian]

really...pixelly

freaking great concept though.

here you go btw

http://www.gimp.org/

[SSJ4HP]

I'm using the oldest photoshop ever created, lol. Thanks for the link.

[Blitz]

i'll take a rating for Radian's newest signature. Yay for Soren :)

[Radian]

no problem. if you ever need a hand with the GIMP, let me know, i'll give you a few pointers.

[Okashii]

I could use help with font and gimp XD How do you do good font effects?
http://fc06.deviantart.com/fs32/f/2008/204/b/b/Knight_of_Seven_by_EvanTandem.jpg

see how the font work really sucks?

(image from http://www.designchronicle.com/memento/ ... 0105LG.jpg (http://www.designchronicle.com/memento/images/codegeassR2/01/ED0105LG.jpg))

[pylar55]

i give okashii's sig a 8

[Okashii]

lol thanks :P which one?? O.O the one I posted or one in my actual sig?

[SSJ4HP]

Would somebody give my new sig a rating? I dropped Gimp, and worked with photoshop some more. I found out how to get rid of pixellation and how to make borders.

[pylar55]

lol thanks :P which one?? O.O the one I posted or one in my actual sig?

Your Actual Sig, if i was rating the one you posted id prolly give it a 9 i like the effects and the front looks good to me

[Okashii]

yeah I just wish I would've put my name on it XD Cause I like it a lot better lol. (and for some reason I cant find intermediate saves, and i dunno wtf happened to mah layers :(

[Blitz]

Okashii, you should go back and fix the text on that other sig, it was pretty cool

[Okashii]

the one with Hitsukun's name? I want to XD

[Xaros]

1st sig - 8/10 I really like how the characters are like shaded or shadowed or w/e. Really fits in well. They appear in an Anime?

2nd sig - 8/10 I really like this one, the design in the back is pretty cool, and the whole outline in red is cool. The armor on the knights are pretty bad ass as well :D

[Woosh]

Waha! I love looking at my old work xD. (top)

Top: 7/10. I've done better :P
Bottom: 8.9/10 Eliwood was great with effects.

[Xaros]

Conceited A.hole! lmao kidding! D: You mean to tell me you half @$$ed my request!? How dare you, I demand a RE-DO! lol

1st one - 8.5 | Although it is a bit plain, I love it. Srsly, Who doesn't love your friendly neighborhood spiderman!?

2nd one - 1/10 *British Accent* "Stop Tryin!" Stop makin sigs whoever made this disgrace! xD
lmao just kiddin 9/10 Its really cool. The org. pic is what makes it bad ass. Also, my terms of sigging aint great but the "lighting" of the thing and Link being shadowed makes him look like hes gonna rape you O.O

[pylar55]

wow woosh is pretty good at sigs huh?? i give xaros

8
8

very cool

[Okashii]

7/10 for the clan sig
only reserve is I would've liked to have seen a little bit of color, but that's just my preference XD

[Blitz]

can somone rate mine, i might make a new ones...

[Xaros]

7/10 Too big IMO :\ i d k. the design is what gives it its score.

[SSJ4HP]

No one rated mine when I posted two pages ago, lol.

[Blitz]

I rate yours a 7/10 i like the colours, and the icy effect on the ball, good job on getting rid of the pixels, i suggest you start trying gimp, thats what i use =)

somone please rate mine

[pylar55]

i like 8.5 ot of 10 very cool quake

[Blitz]

somone rate these ones please? (the ones in the post, not the ones i have on now..even though they might be the same)

http://i338.photobucket.com/albums/n435/QuakeQuake8/falcoco.jpg
http://i338.photobucket.com/albums/n435/QuakeQuake8/olinarrrr.jpg
http://i163.photobucket.com/albums/t285/meee_056/KilikSigSmaller.png

[Okashii]

by radian: 9/10 Its just big with the others in the sig as well so maybe if it was alone I could tell better? Its really nice though

by Wavve: 6/10 the way presented here, 8/10 as presented together as tags like wavebird had in the other thread. The only real problem I have are the pikmin colors. Maybe just me but something clashes with my eyes a little bit?

[Blitz]

i kinda liked the fact the pikmin were off coloured, I'm tired of everything having to match...

And, yeah I do have radians and wavvE's seperated, i only had em like that for awhile so i could test...

Thanks though!

[nsoul]

Someone rate my sig?

[Hitsukun]

I think its pretty good...(8.7/10)
I think that this would be about perfect if the lighting was different.
To me, i think it would look better if it had less Xach-effect but that
may be just me.

[Blitz]

i think it looks like a... (8.3/10)

It's cool but i agree with hits, the lighting on it makes it kinda look dull and all faded...but some people like that, so 8+ are good if you get it from 2 people, cause lots of this stuff if the raters look on things..

[Blitz]

Can somone rate mine again? now it isn't so big..

[Radian]

still fricken big. 6/10

just kidding. im not allowed to rate my own signatures

[Blitz]

I just made my own sig, somone feel like rating it?

[Okashii]

7/10 - font is hard to read but I like the colors :)

[Blitz]

Yeha i know the font is really hard, i'm trying to fix it but i already flattened the image >:(

[Okashii]

ahhh haha... I save flattened images as a separate file so i never do that :P

[Radian]

in The GIMP save everything twice. Once as an .xcf file and once as a .png

.xcf saves everything. your layers, your paths, you undos, everything.

[Okashii]

yup thats exactly what I do :)

[[NeW]TearZ]

...My apologies. I am unable to see any sigs on my mobile device.

[Okashii]

aw that sucks
id hate to have to browse and not see all the custom stuff :(

btw ill give your sig an 8.5/10 I like it :)

[SpikeDragon]

I give Oka's 9.2/10

I like it, only I can't tell what the top one is.

[Okashii]

ROFL no one seems to be able to :(
Its a butterfly :)

I giver yours a 9/10 7 of those just for the sweet font :)

[Berty200]

um... 9 outta 10? I like the font and the pic.

[Okashii]

Radian... the new sig is really awesome, even better than the first power one. 9.8/10 i love the conce[t and colors and the font and what it says just great :)

[Legendary Dragoon]

9/10, That's a cool looking Sig.

[SIR SPILZ A LOT]

all of yalls sigs are sooooooooo much better than mine.
I really need a new better lookin one.

i give legendary dragoon a 8/10

[Blitz]

Well spilz, since your above me I'll rate that sweet sig radian made for you :)

I'll give it a 9/10

It would definatly be a 10 if the dragon looked further away, he looks kinda likes he's sitting on top of the dragon, and theres not much of a border, but it's definatly one of my top 5 fav sigs on this site,

my favorite sigs on this site.

1. My Falco sig [Made by Radian]
2. Jonus's Resident evil sig [Made by ultie]
3. Zantetsuken's Lucario sig [Made by himself]
4. Radians Bass sig [Made by himself]
5. Sir Spilz Alot's Knight sig [made by radian]

PS: Can somone rate mine since i'm here? :)

[SIR SPILZ A LOT]

thax blitz and i give u a 9.5/10 cause urs is awesome but da only thing i can c dats wrong wit it is dat the background falco on the right is the same as the one on the left just flipped over.

but radian makes some awesome sigs tho

[Mariyah]

I give it 8.5/10

[Blitz]

Lol, there not the same XD

Left one is of him doing his Falco phantasm and the right he's shooting his gun :)

[SIR SPILZ A LOT]

Lol, there not the same XD

Left one is of him doing his Falco phantasm and the right he's shooting his gun :)

oh my bad blitz den i give it a 9.8 out of ten

[Ender]

I give that thar sig a 6/10. It is very simple and the lighting is just a tad off, but I like the font and the monochromatic style gives extra emphasis to the blood in the sig.

Kudos. Did I spell that right?

[Radian]

ugh, the lighting was a bitch on that one -.-

i was trying to make the dragon look like a memory of the knight. haha oh well. and as for simplicity, thats mor eor less my style :)

as for yours, Nice colours, good effects (specially around the render) GREAT game, i give it a 9/10. I dunno why, but thhe text placement kind bugs me. Maybe if it were moved to the corners and you got some pins or maybe joshua's cards scattered around that area?

[Ender]

Ohhh...I get it now, I like your memory idea!
Hmmm... I may try that card thing....!